Silence, for the Sake of Peace

Deep down, I believe that saving lives, helping people, is the most important thing, no matter which side you’re on.

January 15th, 2009 | by Anna Kramer

There are a few things we don’t talk about in my family. And one of them is the situation in Israel and Palestine.

It all started with an argument with my dad a few years ago. My dad is an open-minded guy, good-humored, always willing to help others, and able to see both sides of any issue. As I grow older, I see how his values of tolerance and service have shaped my own personal beliefs. These days, we often talk about politics, and we almost always see eye to eye.

But on the subject of Israel, my dad usually has strong feelings. Rooted in his heritage, and his emphasis on the importance of family, his beliefs arise from the fact that we have relatives living in Israel now, who fled there from Eastern Europe two generations ago. They reflect a lifelong wish to visit Israel, even if my mom won’t let him (too dangerous!). They come from 50-plus years of reciting the same prayer, every spring, at Passover Seder: “Next year in Jerusalem.”

Those beliefs are his. They’re not necessarily shared by everyone in my family.

So, after our argument a few years ago, this is one issue we don’t talk about at family gatherings–for the sake of keeping the peace.

Of course, the current crisis in Gaza–and Oxfam’s response–has brought this issue to my mind again. I’m glad that Oxfam strives not to take sides or get involved in political disputes. We’re responding to the humanitarian crisis in Gaza as we would to any humanitarian crisis anywhere: because civilians and families are at risk and need help.

But of course, this isn’t just any crisis, and it raises strong feelings among many Americans. I know because some of my fellow Oxfam staffers wrestle with the same issues. Some, like me, feel a little uncomfortable whenever the subject comes up, because it touches on personal stuff–like family and faith. Others have visited Gaza as aid workers, and feel shocked by the loss of lives and the destruction they’ve witnessed. Just because you work at Oxfam doesn’t mean you can easily set those feelings aside.

Even so, I’m trying hard to keep an open mind about the ongoing conflict in the Middle East. I’m a realist, so I think that peace will be difficult, and tenuous, and will probably require sacrifice on both sides. But for right now, in Gaza, I can see that an immediate ceasefire is the only way to stop people from suffering.

Deep down, I believe that saving lives, helping people, is the most important thing, no matter which side you’re on.

I guess it’s just the way I was raised.

Comments

6 Responses to “Silence, for the Sake of Peace”

  1. It’s funny that in an area named “The Holy Land” that the act of forgiveness is so hard to muster (on both sides of the dispute!)

  2. Beautifully put, Anna. Well done! Suffering is suffering, and death is death–we can leave the politics to the politicians.

  3. Amen.

  4. I think both sides leaders don’t give a damn about human life if they did then they would have resolved their issues a long time ago. There are a few powerful people profiting from this timeless war and this conflict will never end. The older I get the more cynical I become in human goodness and this conflict just adds fuel to my cynicism.

    There is a light at the end of the tunnel though and OXFAM need to be congratulated in all that they do not only in the Israel-Palestine conflict but all over the world. I know what Anna goes though because my dad is also politically minded and there are certain issue when brought up just leads to an endless argument…

  5. Nicely put!
    I am lebanese ! as a middle eastern citizen I feel devastated to see the amount of loss and death taking lace everyday! what breaks my heart even more is that we as ARABs especially the the arab league are hardly doing anything about it! All i see are dead children an women on the streets some being left alive to be eaten by strayed dogs…
    Human rights is for all NO EXCEPTIONS!
    I just hope this Genocide ends soon!

  6. Martin Luther King Jr. once said that, ” it is not what our enemies have said that we will remember, but rather, the silence of our freinds. ” ( as best as I can remember). To keep silent when such evil is done to our fellow man makes cowards of us all. I am a Christian and I am ashamed of the response, or lack of, that my fellow believers have exhibited to this humanitarian nightmare. God Bless those precious suffering ones.

Join the discussion

Author

Anna Kramer

Anna Kramer

Writer Anna Kramer joined Oxfam America in 2005. Based in Boston, she covers a broad range of issues for Oxfam, with a focus on our campaigns and organizing work.

See more posts from Anna Kramer